The Albanese Government’s dramatic backdown on its Working Holiday Maker visa restrictions is an admission that its original proposals were fundamentally flawed and completely misjudged.
However, there is no denying the revised arrangements are still a cut on last year’s figures.
Federal Member for Hinkler David Batt MP said the announcement by Immigration Minister Tony Burke confirmed precisely what the Coalition and Hinkler farming and tourism businesses had cautioned from the outset.
“The Coalition and industry stakeholders warned very clearly that Labor’s original proposed restrictions would threaten jobs, local businesses and agricultural production here in Hinkler,” Mr Batt said.
The latest changes require working holiday-makers to complete 120 days of regional work, up from 88, to qualify for a second-year visa.
The planned cap for third-year visas will also rise to 25,000, with the rollout of a ballot for places now delayed until next year.
But that intake figure is still lower than the historical figures and to be honest many farmers fear the damage has already been done.
“It’s another Labor reversal, instead of consulting with and listening to those industries before making its original announcement, Labor pressed ahead with poorly conceived restrictions and created completely unnecessary uncertainty for regional employers and Working Holiday Makers.”
The Coalition remains committed to reducing overall migration to sustainable levels, while ensuring that Australia’s immigration system responded to genuine workforce needs. “Australia needs a migration program that reflects our housing and infrastructure capacity, and that means abandoning Labor’s approach and actually recognising the particular needs of regional communities and industries that rely on seasonal and temporary workers,” Mr Batt explained.
“The Coalition has a clear and constructive alternative policy, which will encourage Working Holiday Makers to travel to where they are needed most. Labor’s backdown doesn’t change the fact farmers are still being asked to plan their harvest workforce around a chook raffle.”
Labor clearly doesn’t understand how heavily farmers rely on Working Holiday Makers. Any cut to the raw numbers will hit farmers harder than other industries, because the seasonal nature of harvest work means growers depend on these workers being available at the right place and the right time.”
“We will abolish arbitrary caps and bureaucratic ballots, introduce visa fee concessions for Working Holiday Makers undertaking regional work, and review the definition of regional Australia to better target genuine workforce shortages.”
Bundaberg Fruit & Vegetable Growers Chief Executive Officer Bree Watson said horticulture is seasonal by its very nature, and growers need confidence that workers will be available throughout the year to meet the changing demands of planting and harvesting.
“Working holiday makers are an important part of that workforce. They work, they holiday, and they share their experiences with friends and family back home. When they have a great experience in the regions, they become our best ambassadors,” Ms Watson explains.
“The recently released Wide Bay Burnett Horticulture Economic Report 2024–25, confirms the significant contribution horticulture makes to our region, including:
- More than $1.386 billion contributed to the Wide Bay Burnett’s Gross Regional
Product; - A horticultural farm-gate value of $958.5 million;
- More than 2,000 farms producing over 40 different crops;
- 4,392 direct jobs and 12,548 seasonal jobs supported.
Notes: Friday November 20 is National Agriculture Day. The final Parliamentary sitting week of the year will be held for the House of Representatives in Canberra next week.